The MSI-BPD is a 10-question yes/no screening questionnaire for borderline personality disorder (BPD). A score of 7 or more suggests a full assessment is worthwhile, but it cannot diagnose BPD. It is a first step, not a label.
A few key points before we go through it:
- A screening score only tells you whether a fuller assessment is worth having. It is not a diagnosis.
- Each “yes” scores one point, giving a total from 0 to 10.
- A score of 7 or more is the traditional cut-off, and scores of 5–6 are a grey zone.
- The MSI-BPD can miss people with BPD and can flag people who don’t have it.
- BPD is treatable, and many people improve a lot with the right support.
What Is the MSI-BPD (McLean Screening Instrument)?
The MSI-BPD, or McLean Screening Instrument for Borderline Personality Disorder, is a 10-question yes/no questionnaire that helps flag whether a fuller assessment for BPD is worthwhile. It was developed by Mary Zanarini and colleagues at McLean Hospital and published in 2003. It screens only. It cannot diagnose.
The questions come from the BPD module of the DIPD-IV, a structured interview based on DSM criteria. In the original study, 200 people aged 18 to 59 with treatment histories completed it (Zanarini et al., 2003). The MSI-BPD screens for signs of borderline personality disorder in a few minutes. Researchers and clinicians use it as a BPD screening questionnaire in many countries, and it has been translated into several languages.
What Does the MSI-BPD Ask?
The MSI-BPD asks about ten areas drawn from the diagnostic criteria for BPD. These cover relationships, self-harm, impulsive behaviour, mood changes, anger, mistrust, emptiness, identity, fear of abandonment, and feeling unreal. Each is answered yes or no, based on your own experience.
We don’t reproduce the questions word for word, but here are the ten areas in plain language:
- Intense, unstable relationships
- Deliberately hurting yourself
- Impulsive behaviour, such as in spending, eating, or other areas
- Strong, shifting moods
- Intense or hard-to-control anger
- Feeling mistrustful or suspicious of others
- Feeling empty
- Uncertainty about who you are
- Fear of being abandoned
- Feeling unreal or disconnected, particularly under stress
Each question maps to one of the main signs of BPD. Many of these experiences are common in everyday life and in other conditions. What matters is how strong and persistent they are.
How Is the MSI-BPD Scored?
You score one point for every “yes”, with no points for “no”. That gives a total between 0 and 10. A higher score means more of the screened experiences apply to you. Scoring is simple, but interpreting it is not, and only a clinician can put the result in context.
A worked example: Imagine someone answers “yes” to six of the ten questions. Their score is 6. That falls in the 5–6 grey zone, which means BPD can’t be ruled out, and it may be worth talking to a health professional. It does not mean they have BPD.
MSI-BPD Cut-Off: What Your Score Means
| Score | What it suggests | A sensible next step |
|---|---|---|
| 0–4 | Below the usual cut-off. BPD is less likely, though a screening score can’t rule it out | If you’re struggling, talk to your GP about what’s going on |
| 5–6 | A grey zone. BPD can’t be ruled out, and some researchers suggest this range deserves attention | Consider a conversation with your GP, especially if distress is affecting your life |
| 7–10 | At or above the traditional cut-off. A fuller assessment is worthwhile | Talk to your GP about a referral for a clinical assessment |
A score is not a diagnosis, and it does not define you.
If you’re feeling distressed or unsafe, you don’t have to wait for an assessment. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14 or the Suicide Call Back Service on 1300 659 467, any time. In an emergency, call 000.
How Accurate Is the MSI-BPD?
In the original study, the MSI-BPD with a cut-off of 7 correctly identified 81% of people with BPD (sensitivity) and correctly ruled out 85% of people without it (specificity). In plain words, it catches most people with BPD and rarely flags people without it, but not always.
That means around 19% of people with BPD score below 7 (Zanarini et al., 2003; Zimmerman & Balling, 2021). Across other studies, sensitivity has ranged from about 48% to 91% and specificity from about 19% to 90%, depending on the group studied and the cut-off used. Researchers have suggested cut-offs anywhere from 5 to 8.
A review of more than 1,473 people found that reaching 90% sensitivity, which matters for a screening tool, needs a cut-off slightly below 7. That’s why some researchers suggest using 5 or 6. This is also why BPD screening accuracy should be treated as a guide, not a verdict.
Most of the original validation research included more women than men, so results for women with BPD are better understood than for other groups.
Is the MSI-BPD Accurate for Young People?
The original study found the MSI-BPD worked better in people aged 25 and under, but later research in adolescents is mixed. Some studies found lower accuracy at the standard cut-off of 7, and suggested 5 or 6. It’s validated for use from age 15. Treat any result as a prompt for assessment, not an answer.
In the original study, people aged 25 or under had a sensitivity of 90% and a specificity of 93% at a cut-off of 7. A later Australian study of young people aged 15 to 24 (Chanen et al., 2008) found lower accuracy at the same cut-off. A French study of adolescents (Mirkovic et al., 2020) found that a cut-off of 5 worked best.
Early recognition matters. Australian research by Andrew Chanen and colleagues at Orygen has supported identifying and treating BPD in young people early. If you’re a parent whose teenager has scored high, it’s a reason to talk with your GP, not a reason for alarm or a label.
Why a BPD Screening Score Can Be Misleading
A screening score can be raised or lowered by things other than BPD. Several conditions and circumstances share features with BPD, including:
- Complex PTSD, which can involve intense emotions, relationship difficulties, and a changed sense of self
- Bipolar disorder, where mood changes can raise your score. It helps to understand whether it’s bipolar or BPD
- ADHD, which can involve impulsivity and emotional reactivity
- Depression and anxiety, which can affect mood, energy and how you see yourself
- Current distress, because how you feel on the day, such as during a crisis or a difficult week, can colour your answers
The reverse can also happen. A score can be low even when someone does have BPD. That’s why a clinician looks at your whole history, not just a number.
Can a Test Diagnose BPD?
No. A screening questionnaire can’t diagnose BPD. Diagnosis usually follows a two-step approach: a quick screening step, then a semi-structured clinical interview with a trained professional, which looks at your history, symptoms, and how they affect your life (Mirkovic et al., 2020).
A questionnaire can help you reflect on your experiences and prompt a conversation, but it can’t capture your full story. Diagnosis is often delayed, and for many people with BPD, more than 10 years can pass between first seeking help and an accurate diagnosis (Magnavita et al., 2010). Starting the conversation sooner can help.
What to Do After a High MSI-BPD Score
Start by seeing your GP. They can listen, check your overall health, and refer you on. A full BPD assessment with a psychiatrist or psychologist looks at your history, not just a questionnaire.
It’s important to know that BPD is treatable, and many people improve a lot. Several therapies have good evidence, including DBT treatment, which has strong evidence for helping people with BPD manage intense emotions, as well as mentalisation-based therapy (MBT). Treatment takes time and effort, but recovery is a realistic goal.
If your score was in the middle or lower but you still relate to some of these experiences, that matters too. Your experience is valid whatever the number says, and it’s okay to ask for support.
MSI-BPD FAQs
Can my MSI-BPD score change over time?
Yes. Your answers depend partly on how you’ve been feeling lately, so a score can rise during a stressful or low period and fall when things settle. That’s one reason a single score isn’t a verdict. If your score changes noticeably, mention it to your GP, because the pattern can be useful information.
Should I take my score to my GP?
It can help. You don’t need the number to start the conversation, but it gives you something concrete to talk through. It’s often more useful to describe what you’ve been experiencing, when it started and how it affects daily life. Your GP will treat the score as a starting point, not a conclusion.
What happens at a BPD assessment?
A clinician usually asks about your current experiences, your history, your relationships and how you cope, sometimes using a structured interview. It can take more than one appointment. You can ask questions along the way. The goal is to understand your whole picture, including other conditions that can look similar, before reaching any conclusion.
Is the MSI-BPD suitable for children under 15?
It’s been validated for people aged 15 and older, so it isn’t designed for younger children. If you’re worried about a child’s emotions or behaviour, start with your GP, who can look at the whole picture and refer to a paediatrician or child and adolescent mental health service if needed.
Is the MSI-BPD used in Australia?
Yes, it has been used in Australian research, including youth mental health studies at Orygen, and clinicians may use it or other screening tools. Not every GP or clinician will use it, and it isn’t required for an assessment. If you want one used, you can ask, but your story matters more than a number.
How long does treatment for BPD take?
It varies. Some therapies, such as full DBT programs, run for many months, and people often continue using the skills afterwards. A clinician can explain what to expect once they know your situation. Progress is usually gradual, with good periods and setbacks, rather than a quick fix.
What if a family member or friend scored high?
Try to stay calm and avoid labelling them. Let them know you care, listen without judgement, and encourage them to talk to their GP about what they’re experiencing. A score isn’t a diagnosis, so avoid telling them they “have” BPD. If they’re in distress or unsafe, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 or 000.
Conclusion
The MSI-BPD is a quick, widely used way to find out whether a fuller assessment for borderline personality disorder is worth having. A score of 7 or more is the traditional cut-off, scores of 5–6 are a grey zone, and no score can diagnose BPD. Screening can miss people with BPD and flag people without it, so it’s best seen as a starting point for a conversation with a health professional.
Whatever your score, your experiences matter, and BPD is treatable. Many people improve a lot with the right support. HelloDoc publishes this guide to help people make sense of BPD screening, so you can take the next step with clear, balanced information.
HelloDoc (Disclaimer and Liability Terms)
HelloDoc aims to connect users with psychiatry professionals. However, we do not guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information shared. The platform does not warrant any professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. All services are offered “as-is,” and users must assess their relevance independently.
HelloDoc is NOT an emergency response platform. All consultations are by appointment only. If you are experiencing a mental health crisis, please seek immediate assistance from emergency services.
For Mental Health Emergencies in Australia, contact:
- Lifeline: 13 11 14
- Beyond Blue: 1300 224 636
- MensLine Australia: 1300 789 978
- Suicide Call Back Service: 1300 659 467
- Veterans and Veterans Families Counselling Service: 1800 011 046
The information on this website, including blog posts, is for general informational purposes only and is not meant to replace or substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or evidence-based treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider for any medical condition or health-related questions. By continuing to use HelloDoc, you accept these terms and acknowledge that they may change without notice.
